In the past two days there have been two new brand new forum users that have posted replies to several threads on this forum, some new threads, and some a bit old. Something about these replies seems a bit off to me, I’m thinking maybe they are actually AI generated. I did a bit of investigating and found that the email addresses for these new forum users don’t match the user names at all, but on the other hand the email addresses seem to be similar to each other, and similar in pattern to addresses I found on a site called Stop Forum Spam. This has never come up before, so I’m not sure if I should ban these users, though as far as I can see the replies posted are not technically incorrect. Does anyone have any thoughts?
I thought the same.
I would prefer to know that all contributors to the forum were genuine human users. Would you consider e-mailing them to establish their credentials?
While I am not a fanatic w regard to the forum, I too felt that they were a bit off from the norm. The phrasing and detail were too precise. As the info did not pertain to anything I could specifically relate to, I brushed them off as just a bit off-topic for my needs. Bottom line though, if they are not inaccurate, they may be helpful to some. On the other hand, bad information is worse than no information so they should be monitored IMHO.
Emailing them may not prove much, since a spammer or AI-assisted account can still answer. A more practical check is whether the addresses are already listed on Stop Forum Spam, plus a quick look at posting cadence and whether the replies actually engage with the thread. If the forum wants human-only contributions, state that clearly and hold first posts for approval; since the replies are technically correct, a warning or rate-limit before banning seems proportionate.
OMG I was reading the new posts from the bottom up and I was having the exact same thought! This sentence made me super suspicious:
Your ServerVariable/FileGlobal pattern is a good one—worth emphasizing that ServerVariable reads a cached value, so assign before reading.
Totally sounds like something an AI would say!
Are you sure? It didn’t offer additional service (Would you like fries with that?) to keep you “on the hook”. ![]()